Have you noticed that the days are getting shorter? Cookie and I are heading out the door earlier for our evening walk, and I’m scrambling to check off the summer recipes on my list while I still can.
Peaches are so plump and sweet right now; popsicles needed to happen. I killed two birds with one stone with these peach popsicles. They’re super simple—consisting of roasted peaches, honey and yogurt—and they taste just like you’d expect. Delicious, fruity and creamy.
These popsicles are ultra creamy because I roasted the peaches into jammy submission, which reduces their water content while concentrating their sweet flavor, and opted for full-fat yogurt, too. Speaking of, every time I specify full-fat yogurt in a recipe, I get questions asking if you can use low-fat yogurt instead. If you use lower fat yogurt in this recipe, which has less fat and more water, you’ll get icier popsicles.
That said, if you don’t share my totally bizarre, nails-on-a-chalkboard-like aversion to icy popsicles (also included: the sound of ice rubbing against ice, please tell me I’m not the only one), you can go ahead and make some with low-fat yogurt.
However! If you’re worried about fat content, I would argue that a) these are reasonably sized, three-ounce treats and, b) full-fat yogurt still isn’t that high in fat or calories. I’m looking at the container right now and just about a third of the calories come from fat, which is nowhere near heavy cream and still less than your average cheese. It’s also very high in protein. For a dairy-free version, try substituting full-fat coconut milk for the yogurt.
Before I go, I got the chance to talk to Gabriel of The Dinner Special the other day. He turned our conversation into a podcast and a YouTube video and transcribed it, too! You can listen/watch/read over here, eep! He has interviewed a ton of other bloggers, too, so you might find some new blogs to love while you’re there.
Creamy Peach & Honey Popsicles
- Author: Cookie and Kate
- Prep Time: 10 mins
- Cook Time: 30 mins
- Total Time: 40 minutes
- Yield: 8 popsicles (24 ounces total) 1x
- Category: Dessert
Honey-sweetened peach popsicles made with yogurt and roasted peaches! These cold, creamy treats are perfect for summertime. They’re healthy, too. Recipe yields eight 3-ounce popsicles.
Ingredients
- 1 pound ripe peaches (about 3 medium), peeled and sliced into ½-inch wide wedges
- 6 tablespoons honey, divided
- Dash sea salt
- 2 cups full fat/whole milk plain yogurt (regular or Greek)
- 1 tablespoon lemon juice (about 1 small lemon, juiced)
- ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Line a rimmed baking sheet with parchment paper. Transfer sliced peaches to the baking sheet and gently toss with 2 tablespoons honey and a dash of salt. Arrange the peaches in a single layer. Roast for 30 to 40 minutes, stirring halfway, or until the peaches are soft and juicy (watch the edges in particular).
- While the fruit is roasting, blend together the yogurt, ¼ cup honey, lemon juice and vanilla extract in a medium bowl. Feel free to add more honey or vanilla extract to suit your taste buds. Place the mixture in the refrigerator so it stays cool.
- Let the peaches cool, then scrape the peaches and all of their juices into the bowl of yogurt. Use a big spoon to gently fold the mixture together.
- Use the spoon to transfer the yogurt blend into the popsicle mould. You might have to push the peaches down into the molds, but they shouldn’t put up too much of a fight. Insert popsicle sticks and freeze for at least four hours.
- When you’re ready to pop out the popsicles, run warm water around the outsides of the moulds for about ten seconds and gently remove the popsicles. Enjoy immediately.
Notes
Recipe adapted from my roasted berry and honey popsicles.
Recommended popsicle mold: I love this American made, BPA-free ice pop mold. If you don’t want to buy a mold, I think you can use Dixie cups or the like.
▸ Nutrition Information
Vegetable enthusiast. Dog lover. I'm probably making a big mess in my Kansas City kitchen right now. 
Bella B
These look so good! I have made several popsicle recipes lately that I have posted on my blog. I never want summer to end!
Eliza | Pen + Pan
Peaches + honey = a classic combination that I could never get enough of. And I’m happy to have any excuse to eat up dreamy, creamy full-fat yogurt.
Esther
These look incredible – the perfect grown up popsicle. Can’t wait to try them.
Jesseca
I love how simple this recipe is. We love roasted peaches and look forward to the season every year. Adding them to a healthy popsicle is kind of genius.
Bet@ Bet On Dinner
These look amazing! I have some push-up popsicle molds and I must admit we haven’t branched out beyond homemade fudgsicles. ;o) We ate our last peaches at breakfast but as soon as I get some more I’m making these! Can’t wait!
Ellie
These look so refreshing and delicious! I’ve been in the market for a popsicle mold – thank you for the recommendation :)
J.S. @ Sun Diego Eats
Could not agree more – begone icy popsicles. Although not sure about the ice rubbing thing will have to pay attention next time haha.
Allyson
Roasting peaches to get rid of the water- what a great idea. And where did you get those popsicle molds from? They look like exactly what I’ve been looking for.
Kate
Thanks, Allyson! I got the molds on Amazon. I added a link to the mold in the recipe notes!
Cassandra
Perfect looking frozen soldiers. They look so creamy and delicious. I will have to try the recipe. Bravo on such beautiful pictures.
Jerilyn
Amazing pictures as always! On this recipe in particular I could not stop my mouth from salivating! Thanks for the great post. :)
Kate
Thank you, Jerilyn! :)
Gabriel @ The Dinner Special podcast
Thanks so much for the shoutout Kate! You were such a fun guest! I had such an awesome time chatting with you! And these yogurt pops – love how the peaches are peeking through the frozen goodness!
Joanne
I am a full fat yogurt purist in ALL THINGS. I just don’t think anyone ever got fat from eating full fat yogurt, of all things! These popsicles are summer glory at its finest.
Kate
High five, Joanne! Seems like we run on the same wavelength. :)
Angela - Patisserie Makes Perfect
Oh Kate – when these popped into my inbox I couldn’t believe my eyes. I’m certain we just don’t have iced lolly makers that look like this in the UK – if we do, they’re hiding from me!
These look stunning, I also love that they’re made with yoghurt. I adore ice-cream, but it really doesn’t like me, so it’s nice to have something with yoghurt instead.
Beverley @ sweaty&fit
Ahhh why does summer have to be ending?! The worst part of the year :(
these look so delicious i need to get myself some popsicle molds STAT
Eva
So yummy, I want to try them!
Your blog is really nice, love it :)
Brittany
I’m feeling the same way about summer produce! Enjoying every last piece of it since I know fall is just around the corner.
These pops look awesome.
Cindy
These look incredible and so easy (win/win)! I agree, full-fat yogurt all the way for frozen treats.
Gaby Dalkin
Simplicity at it’s best! Peaches and honey are the best together!! What a great afternoon snack
Sarah @ Making Thyme for Health
I have noticed the days are getting shorter and it’s making me sad! I’m not ready for summer to end.
These Popsicles look like the best way possible to hold onto to what’s left of it. Your pictures are gorgeous. I’m drooling just thinking about how good they must taste!
Ingrid - For the love of Pie
Lovely recipe Kate! And nice interview too!
Kate
Thank you, Ingrid!
Melissa
Hi Kate,
I’m not a fan of large fruit chunks in my yogurt, frozen or otherwise. Would this recipe work as well if I puréed the peaches after roasting?
Thanks! These look incredible!
Kate
Hi Melissa! Yes, I think they’d be great that way. You might roast an extra peach just to make sure the blended yogurt tastes good and peachy.
Judith
I recently found myself with 20 pounds of peaches and immediately thought of making popsicles! So glad I came across this recipe. They turned out amazing and make for a great afternoon treat.
https://aluminumfoiledkitchen.wordpress.com/2016/09/14/when-you-have-20-pounds-of-peaches/
Bonnie DeLeon
I love your recipes. We need more healthy recipes.
Kate
Thank you, Bonnie! I have lots of healthy recipes for you. :)
Ada Madelhari @ My Quirky Creation
These look so charming, delightful and mouthwatering! What a great flavor combo!
Kate
Thanks, Ada! I hope you love them.
Joan
Hi Kate, I made strawberry yogurt Popsicles with no fat Greek yogurt and he was a little icy, but that’s not what I don’t like.. I just don’t like the tang of yogurt. I wanted to taste like vanilla ice cream.but I’m watching my calories so I can’t use cream. I love the idea of coconut milk and I’m going to try it and let you know. Love your blog it looks so pretty.
Kate
Yes, I think you’d like this one, Joan! Let me know how it goes.
Chris Vasco
I really like your recipes and have tried a few. So thanks for the tips. I was wondering if i was able to give you a tip in return. I noticed in a few of your pictures that your popsicle sticks are not straight. I’ve been making popsicles for a few years now and use the same moulds you are using. I’ve found the best results and cheapest way to keep them straight is to use small and medium size chip clips. I’ve been able to find them at the dollar store and work great.
Kate
That’s a really great tip! Thank you for sharing, Chris. I appreciate it!
Jinjuta Akkharawisutcharoen
OMG!!!! I LOVE PEACH. It looks so fantastic and easy to make. I’d try to make it myself. Thanks for sharing this!! :-)
Kate
You are welcome! Enjoy :)
Chanidapa0691
look very easy to do and very appetizing
Lynett O'Dell
I really like this recipe but I used my fresh rhubarb instead. I roasted it just like the peaches. A bit tart but could have used a bit more sweetener.
Kate
Thanks for sharing, Lynett!
Samantha
Saw in your “What to cook in July” post that no one reviewed this recipe yet and so I thought I’d leave one. It was a high of 95 the other day here in Ohio so nice cold popsicle sounded terrific and luckily I had everything I needed for them. Everything about this recipe screams delicious and boy did it deliver! The popsicles have a lovely tang but also a hint of sweetness and are very refreshing on these blazing hot summer days! Thanks for the great recipe!
Kate
Thanks for reviewing, Samantha! I appreciate it.
E11B11
I cut the recipe in thirds and made these for my toddler using mini pop molds.
Turned out creamy and excellent!
Kate
Thank you!
Julie P.
Hi, Kate! I am new to your blog. I went searching for peach popsicle recipes and yours looked the best (and had the best reviews/stars). I am excited to try these!! I was looking for ‘shelf date’ to see how long they could last in the freezer before they start to get chrystally… I came into a basket of peaches and they’re ready to be used up. I thought Popsicles would be the best way to preserve them (before going the jam route).
How long would you say these can last in the freezer before they lose their awesomeness?? This will help me determine how many batches to make before I need to make jam or another peachy recipe.
Kate
Hi Julie, I hope you love it! I think it depends on the type of Popsicle mold you use. Typically food lasts 3-6 months well in the freezer, but I haven’t had these last that long to test that theory. Sorry!
Jacqueline
Hi,
Thank you for all your wonderful recipes you have a beautiful dog. God bless both of you. How old is your dog now? I wish both of you a wonderful day.
Thank you
Jacqueline (Animal lover
Pallavi
Made these – so delish!
Kate
Thank you, Pallavi!
Jann
The link you have for yogurt cups like this is definitely not linking to yogurt cups
Kate
Hi Jann, I’m sorry you are having trouble! I will investigate.
Brenda
Can you use frozen peaches?
Kate
It would be worth a try! Defrost them first.
Juliana S
Hey Kate, Love the recipe! Turned out great, but I thought I’d just mention that peeling the peaches beforehand isn’t really necessary. I roasted mine with the skins and easily pulled the skins off 15 minutes into roasting. No peeler or blanching necessary :)
Kal
Can’t wait to try these! I don’t want to buy freezer molds, so I will do this with cups. Looks delicious!
Kate
Thank you for letting me know, Kal! I removed the link (seems like the original website has disappeared). Hope you enjoy these popsicles!
Ashley
This recipe sounds divine, would canned peaches work as well?
Kate
Hi Ashley! It would be worth a try! Defrost them first.
Karen Bostic
Can you substitute sugar for honey ? And how much ?
Kate
Hi Karen! This is designed for a liquid sweetener. I’m not sure it would work without trying it.
Sara
Thanks for another awesome recipe. These are super easy and just as delicious! Follow the recipe and you get a yummy peaches and cream popcicle. Roasting the peaches to get rid of water is worth the extra step. Plus it’s easy to adjust sweetner based on how sweet the peaches are. Full fat yogurt is the way to go. First batch I used the 2% greek yogurt I had on hand and sure enough they were good, but icy. Second batch got full fat yogurt and yay not icy! Ps ice scraping ice IS terrible.
Brooklyn
I am a big believer in fresh fruit and veggies, but in reality, could fresh peaches be substituted for canned? Maybe without cooking them down? Also, are there any other fruits (mango maybe) that we could use with the peaches or on their own? Thanks so much, love your recipes.
Kate
Hi Brooklyn, I haven’t tried it with canned so I can’t say for sure, sorry. I don’t tend to do canned fruit. Frozen, thawed may work. Let me know if you try it!
brooklyn
Okay sounds good. Thank you! Frozen, thawed would be a good experiment!
Rita Z
I have had success with using fruit puree and layering with coconut milk mixed with sweetened condensed milk. Absolutely delicious
Mallory
My husband and my favorite recipe! Are you able to substitute the peaches for other fruits? Was thinking strawberry or raspberry!
Kate
I’m so glad! Yes, you can! I actually have a roasted berry popsicle recipe that’s like this one, for your reference.
Corinna Carter
Hello! Can I Blanche the peaches for pealing?
Kate
Hi, yes, that would work well!
Noelle
Hi! What are your thoughts about using full fat VANILLA flavored yogurt? Also, have you noticed much of a consistency difference between using normal vs Greek yogurt?
Kate
Hi! I prefer what is listed here so they aren’t too sweet.
Debi
I am new to making popsicles (anyone price Outshine fruit popsicles lately?) and have tries a lot of recipes. These are my favorite popsicles by far! Thank you for this one, Kate! The peaches are perfectly sweet and soft and the yogurt is creamy and rich. I may try this methodology with fresh cherries to see how they turn out.
Sarah
Delicious, easy, actually creamy (often these kinds of popsicles turn out very icy and less creamy) – thank you!
Kate
You’re welcome, Sarah! I appreciate your review.
Meri Schroeder
Another winning recipe! My husband, granddaughter and myself went peach picking and I’ve made one batch of popsicles so far. They’re so refreshing and easy to make. So far two of the grandkids have tried them, I ate one, and gave two to our neighbors (she broke her arm so thought this would be a nice treat). We all have enjoyed them!
Edwyna Spiegel
I am lactose intolerant. I can only tolerate Silk’s unsweetened vanilla soy yogurts. Could I use this type of yogurt in the peach crisp recipe?
Kate
You can try it. Let me know what you think, Edwyna!
Birdie
These sounds delicious! Do you think it would work to blend the peaches after roasting for a smooth popsicle mixture?
Kate
You could try it. Let me know what you think if you do!