I never truly loved a potato salad, until I made this one. This potato salad recipe is a riff on classic French potato salads, which contain no mayo and lots of herbs. I opted for lemon juice instead of vinegar for a super fresh-tasting salad.
Unlike standard potato salads that are drenched in mayonnaise, this red potato salad is lightly creamy yet miraculously mayo-free. This potato salad recipe is special diet friendly, too. It’s vegan, egg-free, dairy-free and gluten-free for all to enjoy.
Can I go ahead and call it the perfect potluck potato salad?
This potato salad is for my fellow last-minute people. When you’re scrambling to make yourself look decent, trying to scrounge together a side dish worth sharing, and letting the dog out all at the same time… Potato salad to the rescue!
This recipe is surprisingly simple and quick to make. I hope this potato salad becomes your go-to potluck recipe, as well as a standard side dish at your dinner table. It goes great with burgers, sandwiches, and much more.
Potato Salad Tips
After some trial and error, I’ve discovered some key tips to making great potato salad.
- To make the best mayo-free potato salad, reserve some potato cooking water before draining the potatoes. Then, blend the herbs and olive oil with the starchy reserved water. You’ll end up with a creamy emulsification that infuses the potatoes with fresh flavor.
- Another trick is to slice your potatoes before boiling, rather than afterward. That way, the potatoes don’t break down into mush when you’re tossing the salad later. Plus, your potatoes cook faster this way (five minutes!). We can thank the experts at America’s Test Kitchen for this technique.
Please let me know how you like this potato salad in the comments! I love to hear from you.
Looking for more fresh side dishes? You’ll find more side dish recipes here. Here are a few that would go well with this potato salad:
Watch How to Make Potato Salad
Herbed Potato Salad
- Author: Cookie and Kate
- Prep Time: 20 mins
- Cook Time: 5 mins
- Total Time: 25 minutes
- Yield: 6 side servings 1x
- Category: Salad
- Method: Stovetop
- Cuisine: French
This healthy potato salad recipe is full of fresh flavor. It’s mayo-free, easy to make, and sure to be a hit at your potluck! This salad is vegan, egg free and gluten free. Recipe yields 6 side servings.
Ingredients
- 2 pounds small red potatoes, scrubbed and sliced into ¼-inch thick rounds
- 1 tablespoon fine sea salt
- ¼ cup olive oil
- ⅓ cup lightly packed fresh flat-leaf parsley, roughly chopped, plus about 2 tablespoons more for garnish
- ⅓ cup roughly chopped green onions, plus about 2 tablespoons thinly sliced for garnish
- 2 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
- 2 teaspoons Dijon mustard
- 2 cloves garlic, roughly chopped
- Freshly ground black pepper, to taste
- 3 stalks celery, chopped
Instructions
- In a large saucepan or Dutch oven combine sliced potatoes and salt. Cover with water by 1 inch. Bring to a boil over high heat, then reduce heat to medium-low and cook until potatoes are easily pierced by a paring knife and pulled out with little resistance, about 5 to 6 minutes.
- Reserve ¼ cup cooking water, then drain. Transfer the potatoes to a large mixing bowl.
- In a small food processor or blender, combine the olive oil, ⅓ cup parsley, ⅓ cup green onions, lemon juice, Dijon mustard, garlic and freshly ground black pepper. Process until the herbs and garlic have been chopped into little pieces. Then, while running the food processor, pour in the reserved cooking water and process just until blended. (If you don’t have a food processor or blender, just finely chop the parsley and onions and whisk the dressing together until the oil is fully incorporated.)
- Drizzle the potatoes with the herbed olive oil mixture and gently mix to combine. (It will look like you’ve poured in too much dressing, but don’t worry, the potatoes will soak it up!) Let the potatoes rest for ten minutes, gently tossing every few minutes.
- Add the celery to the bowl, along with a couple tablespoons each of additional chopped parsley and green onions. Toss again. Season generously to taste with salt and pepper.
- Serve immediately, or cover and refrigerate until you’re ready to serve. This salad is best served within a few hours, but will keep in the refrigerator for about three days.
Notes
Recipe roughly adapted from America’s Test Kitchen’s The Complete Vegetarian Cookbook and The Sprouted Kitchen Bowl and Spoon.
Suggested equipment: I love my 11-cup Cuisinart food processor (affiliate link).
Vegetable enthusiast. Dog lover. I'm probably making a big mess in my Kansas City kitchen right now. 
Ilona
Made this today exactly as written, my 3yo loved helping me with it and found the bright green color of the dressing hilarious! :D No vegans here but I was looking for a light, springtime-ish side dish to go with some grilled salmon and it was fabulous! Love from the Netherlands :) :)
Kate
That’s great! I’m glad your kid enjoyed it. Thank you for taking time to review, Ilona!
Katharine
Wow. This is phenomenal! I used fresh chives from my garden instead of green onion and still perfection. Best potato salad.
Kate
Sounds just perfect! I love the home gardening addition. Thank you for your review, Katharine!
Anne
Great and easy recipe! Would be good with any number of fresh spring veg instead of or in addition to the celery (blanched asparagus, peas, etc). Perfect for hot weather, quick to make and has a refreshing taste.
Kate
Yes! Great for warmer weather, Anne. Thank you for sharing.
RF
I didn’t have parsley, so I used kale. I also threw in some chives from the yard. Totally worked!
Kate
I’m happy it worked out, RF! Thank you for your review.
Marie Gauthier
Wonderful, versatile recipe. I needed to use up veggies in my fridge, so I ended up with a mix of potatoes, broccoli, sweet potato, carrots, and some asparagus. It made a huge bowl, so I adjusted the other ingredients except for the salt, which I actually cut in half. Excellent results.
Amy
I have an abundance of Yukon potatoes from the garden, do you think that would be an okay replacement for red potatoes?
Kate
They tend to cook differently, so you may need to adjust the time here. Let me know how it turns out. I find red work the best.
Mary L.
I just tried this recipe for the first time and it’s delicious! I used small Yukon gold potatoes and they worked well, just don’t overcook them. I also used green beans instead of celery and added fresh basil ribbons at the tables. I’m thinking next time we’ll have Greek olives and feta cheese on the side to add to taste. A new favorite recipe – thanks!
Kate
Great to hear, Mary! Thank you for your review.
Suzanne
Yum! I’ve made this twice now and next time will try to remember to add a bit of shallot and a bit more lemon to brighten things up. But I love all the herby-ness!
Kate
Great to hear, Suzanne!
Dorothy Pickles
I love this dish. We are improvising our next batch adding cilantro to the dressing and adding more lemon.
Kate
That’s great to hear, Dorothy! Thank you for you review.
Cassie
Do you think this would be good with dill instead of parsley? My Aerogarden is overflowing with dill.
Kate
I recommend this as is. If you try it, let me know what you think!
Cassie
I tried it with the dill swap. Still delicious! Good reviews from my family who enjoyed it.
Kate
Thank you for reporting back, Cassie!
Fati
I am so addicted to this dressing. I use it on my roasted potatos, as a dip for olive ciabatta or literally any sandwich I make.. the day before i run out, i make more.. It is super delicious.!!! Thank you!!!! :)
Kate
I like that you make this to have with other things! Thank you for sharing, Fati.
Julia
Just found my new Go-To Potato Salad recipe. Spectacular! I can’t eat onions or garlic so left those out and added some baby chard from the garden – with stems – to replace the green onions and wee bit more mustard to make up for the garlic. Thank you!
Kate
You’re welcome, Julia! I’m glad this salad is a go-to for you.
Elaine
Absolutely delish potato salad. I can see this dressing on seafood pasta!
Heidi
I love your recipes and have made many! This is another winner!! We had 10 people here, yesterday, for a Father’s Day BBQ. I made this potato salad and it was a HUGE hit! Even with the “die hard mayo potato salad” fans. Well done! Thank you so much!
Kate
I love it, Heidi! I’m happy you have been enjoying so many recipes.
Christine T
I loved this but unfortunately my fam did not. Next time I will pay more attention the size of my garlic gloves ;) and more fresh parsley vs frozen from last year’s garden. When eaten warm it reminded me of my Grandma’s German potato salad. I did find the slices hard to mix but they didn’t fall apart like you said. I had extra dressing, which made a great condiment for the grilled chicken I made to go with the potatos. Thanks! c
Kate
I’m sorry it wasn’t a hit! Yes, size can vary. Thank you for your feedback, Chrisitne.
Flo
Can’t wait to try this
Peggy
Great recipe!! So easy and so tasty. Will be making this all summer long!
shelley
great summer salad full of flavour!
Kate
Thank you , Shelley!
Diane Baumann
I made this salad as per recipe, turned out great. It was even better when I added cooked bacon to it, everything is better with bacon, isn’t it??….great recipe will certainly make it again.
Cecelia S.
Easy enough to make (not enough dressing), but I’m sorry -where is the taste? I followed the recipe exactly, used fresh ingredients including fresh herbs ( had to buy a large bunch of parsley for 1/3 cup), I ended up putting some rice vinegar in it for some tang. If I make it again I’m going to have to tweak it more.
Kate
Hi Cecelia, I’m sorry you didn’t enjoy this recipe. I appreciate your feedback.
Cecelia S.
Nothing was lost. I used the leftovers to make it into a warm German potato-type salad, with a couple of additions
SW
A great recipe! And the amount of dressing was small enough that I could make it in my tiny 2c food processor.
Kate
I’m glad you enjoyed it, SW!
Chefyl
Thanks for the easy, mayo-free recipe. I think a bit of relish, if on hand, would be an appropriately flavorful addition.
Amy S
Just bought your book for my mother-in-law’s birthday. It’s so colorful and packed full of flavor-popping, healthy recipes – just like this one. Thank you. Five stars!
Kate
Thank you, Amy! I’m glad you both like it.
susan hanson
I love this salad with the sliced potatoes- and the way to cook them so they don’t fall apart. This salad was a big hit at a neighborhood potluck.
Astaff
Could I make this recipe the day before or is it better the day of?
I think my family will love this as they don’t like mayo.
Kate
Hi! It’s best the day of but can be served leftover as well. I hope you all enjoy it!
Griff Neilson
I am a sucker for potato salad and always have been so I made this one over the weekend and it hit the spot. I loved the hint of parsley and I further loved how it did not over power the dish. Great little spin on this classic and thank you as always for keeping it clean and made from whole foods! I really do appreciate it! :)
Kate
You’re welcome! I’m happy you enjoyed my version.
KathyK
Made this recipe yesterday. Followed the directions exactly with the addition of fresh thyme. It was very, very good and even better the day after. Thank you!
Rebekah Schrot
Was wondering if chopped eggs would be good to add?
Dani
Delicious and easy! Great recipe if you’re lactose intolerant. Will use the dressing recipe for other sides too I think.
Dani
I have made this tons of times now, but instead of slicing the potatoes, I but them into chunkier bites and roast them in the oven. MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I’ve also added shaved brussel sprouts. Such a great recipe!
Joan Entwistle
Delicious! My mother never used mayonnaise, so this is my favorite type of potato salad. The dressing is perfectly balanced with the potatoes. Made this a second time with apple cider vinegar because my lemon was moldy, which I liked even better.
Maggie Tirrell
This is my absolute favorite potato salad! It’s great with breakast, or any time. Love, love, love.
Sine
I must agree with you Kate, I have never been fond of potato salad either…but that has changed. Your potato salad is smashingly delicious! I did add fresh dill but other than that made it as written. Fresh, clean and vibrantly green…
Kate
I’m glad you enjoyed this one, Sine!
Sine
A little tip. I just undercooked the potatoes. I mixed everything together then tried one and it was too firm. Alas, the longer the potatoes sit in the dressing they soften to perfection. The dressing is simply out of this world!
Tipismom
Another amazing Cookie+Kate recipe! It was easy, fresh, and delicious, and we loved the leftovers second day too. We frequently BBQ with a neighbor who “hates mayo,” so this was a huge win. Also, our potato bag was only 1.5 pounds, and it still worked out perfectly keeping everything else the same. Thanks so much for sharing!
Kate
You’re welcome!
Laura
I’ve made this potato salad before, and while good I found a bit on the drier side (perhaps since I traditionally eat mayo based potato salad!). If I wanted to make the dressing a bit creamier, do you think adding some greek yogurt would work?
Kate
Hi Laura, I’m sorry to hear that. I’m not sure adding Greek yogurt would get the same result. Ensure the ratios are correct and not overcook your potatoes for the best result.
Cat
If I needed to make this ahead of time is it best to cook the potatoes and dress the day I serve or prepare it immediately, cover and refrigerate until ready to serve?
Kate
Hi Cat, this is best made right away. It can be refrigerated and served later. I hope it’s a hit!
Michele
This is the first time I made this and it was wonderful! I doubled the recipe and accidentally tripled the Dijon mustard and forgot to double the cooking water, but the dressing was really creamy, thick and delicious! Half of the garlic cloves were very large. I used a food processor and blended the dressing pretty well. I could probably have used a couple more potatoes since it made a lot of dressing. I used the smaller size red potatoes and sliced them a little bit thicker than 1/4 in, closer to 5/16 inch (or 8mm). They took a little longer than 5-6 min. to cook, but I kept checking them to prevent overcooking and they did not fall apart when I stirred the sauce into them. It was so fresh, delicious and flavorful and everyone loved it and wanted the recipe!
T
I have tons of lavage. Can I substitute for the celery?
Emily
My husband loves potato salad, but I have never been a fan. All, I can say is wow!!! This is the most delicious, bright, and refreshing potato salad. It’s perfect for summer.
Eryn
An absolute gem of a potato dish. It allows me to use this as the healthier pairing to my meat. I’ve made it twice, and it’s consistently superb. No need to adjust the recipe (thats rare eh?).
Kate
Hooray! I’m glad you loved it as is, Eryn.
Nancy
Made this tonight sans the celery and it’s amazing!!! Ever heard of Chicken Maison? This recipe taste so similar to their potato salad which is exactly what I was looking for! It’ll definitely be a staple in our home now :)
bets
Can you serve this warm from the oven? If so, what temperature do you recommend?
Kate
Hi Bets, this is meant to be served cold or more at room temperature.
Sharnee Marie Trehan
This is possibly the best potato salad i have EVER made or eaten! Beautiful fresh flavours. Husband loved it too. I didnt have celery but everything else followed exactly as per the recipe. Will definitely be a regular feature on our dinner table.
Kate
I’m so glad you think so, Sharnee! Thank you for taking the time to review.
Sonya
I made this when we were having family over. They love basic regular potato salad, but were super impressed with this one! This is the best potato salad I have ever had. In my opinion, it’s WAY tastier than any store bought mayo potato salad – and guilt-free. It’s healthy but still has that comforting, satisfying richness that traditional potato salad provides. I couldn’t stop sneaking more out of the fridge after, and the next day (excellent left overs!). This is my new go-to potato salad recipe. Thanks, Kate!
Kate
Hi Sonya, I’m glad you loved it! Thank you for your review.
Sarah
Is there anything that could be substituted for mustard? I am not a mustard fan, so don’t have it on hand.
Kate
Hi Sarah, for best results I recommend the mustard. Sorry!
Sarah
Thanks so much for the reply, Kate!
Lucy Cort
Thank you for this recipe. My son does not like eggs or any dish made with Mayonnaise. I’m going to make this for Christmas and will rate it afterwards.
LucyC
Jean
What a surprise of a potato salad! Creamy, delicious, and most of all, no old school butter and cream. The celery at the end is the bomb! Will make again soon!
Kate
That’s great to hear, Jean! Thank you for your review.
Aimee
This will be the second year in a row we will be using this potato salad for our Christmas dinner! Wonderful light flavour, it is the perfect nourishing potato salad. Thank you so much X
Kate
You’re welcome, Aimee!
Nancy
First time making it and it was pretty good. I felt the dressing was a little too lemony so I will add less to start and find that perfect point for us. Also, we added crushed walnuts to ours for an added texture and flavor. Give it a try!
Kate
This dish is so delicious it made it to the Christmas menu and got a repeat performance today. Thank you for a simple, tasty, and much-loved recipe, it’s a winner.
Kate
That’s great to hear, Kate!
Dena
Love this! Will definately be making this again.
Kate
That’s great, Dena!
Andrea
Lovely, my parsley has gone to seed but have a lot of oreganio so used that instead
Karen
Made this without celery (daughter not a fan) but with bacon for about 12 people, everybody raved about it! This will now be a regular in our house. Loved how easy it was and so much fresher and lighter than with cream and sour cream
How long could you keep the dressing in the fridge?
Kate
Hi Karen, I haven’t tried to store the dressing, sorry!
Souly B
Was skeptical at first but this was great! I didn’t use a food processor or whisk, just tossed everything up in a storage container at the end. Delicious and easy!
Beatriz
Its delicious! Thank you!
Kate
Great to hear, Beatriz!
Claire
I made this today for Easter lunch and it was a hit! I skipped the water and rather than blending all the ingredients I just whisked the herbs together and folded them in with the potatoes. Thank you for this light but tasty potato salad!
Kate
Wonderful to hear, Claire! I appreciate your review.
Tina
Would this be okay served warm? Looking forward to making this!
Kate
Hi Tina, I haven’t tried to warm it up once it’s been refrigerated so I’m not sure how it would hold up. It is somewhat warm if you serve it right away.
Carly
This is the best potato salad ever! I also like to put fresh chopped basil in it. I’ve taken this to several cookouts and everyone raves about it! Thank you!
Saskia
Hey Kate, I moved and finally have a kitchen for myself again. And I got back to browsing your archive… oh my!
I found this recipe as I was looking for a potato salad dressing.
OMG! 5 stars for sure, how delicious and creamy. I didn’t have much parsley so I mixed it with cilantro which I love.
It was so easy and it’s delicious and certainly a keeper.
Saved in my favorites… thanks Kate.
I’m having it with waterbuffalo sausages and garlic sauteed green beans…yummy.
Greetings from Vancouver Island.
Kate
I’m happy you came across it! Thank you for taking time to review, Saskia.
Sandy
Tasty recipe but please remove SALT from the ingredient list. I automatically added it to the herb dressing while making this recipe on two different occasions! I thought it seemed a little salty (good but salty). All other recipes just say salt the water and don’t list it as an actual ingredient.
Diane
OMG the BEST Potato Salad ever! I love the fact it doesnt have Mayo! This my new go to! Thank you. When the pototoes where done I put them on a cookie sheet seasoned them with salt and peper and added a splash or two of apple cider vinegar! it adds a extra zip.
Kate
Thank you for your review, Diane!
Tina
I have a citrus allergy, can I substitute the lemon juice for vingear? If yes, which would work best?
Kate
Hi Tina, I recommend this as is. You could try it, but I’m not sure how it would turn out.
Ashley
Such a bright and fresh take on summer potato salad, and a great way to use up leftover herbs in the fridge. Thank you!!
Kate
Thank you for your review, Ashely!
Mick McGeough
Like the recipe, used a little too much oil, but that turned out fine, salad did have a “tangy” taste if I had to describe it, definitely a lack of sweet taste, as it is supposed to, but I wish I could add a tasty dressing or something?
Kate
I’m sorry you didn’t love it. Thank you for your feedback, Mick.
Melissa
This recipe was awesome. I didn’t have any celery, so I used some lovage instead, and it was a hit with the whole family. I will be making this recipe again. Thanks for sharing it with us.
Ximena
Made this today and my wife was super impressed, added some black lentils and avocado for a full yet light dinner for a hot summer day! Defo will repeat and add some goat cheese next time!
Susan
Made this for a pre-July 4th get together with friends. A really nice take on a French style potato salad. I added some edamame which worked out nicely. Delicious!!
Barbara
Made it, but the REALLY lazy way. Nothing went into the blender. Just chopped curly parsley and tossed everything in a large bowl except the potatoes. Substatuted bottled lime juice for lemon. Mixed well, then tossed in the potatoes. Didn’t peel the Yukon Gold potatoes either. I think 1 TABLESPOON of salt is WAY too much…Hope it’s better tomorrow.
Suzanne Mangum
Is it best to use regular or extra-virgin olive oil?
Kate
Hi Suzanne, I typically buy extra-virgin. I hope you try it!
Eileen
I don’t understand why my dressing is green and yours is not? The parsley makes it green your picture is not what it really is! This is misleading.
Kate
Hi Eileen, I’m sorry you feel like this is misleading. Did you add the cooking water? I hope you enjoyed the end result.
James Fox
Hi – This is my go to for potato salad. I just wanted to say Thank You for the numerous recipes you have created that are a part of my cooking repertoire. This dressing also great for many more veggies and a even a drizzle on chicken.
Kate
I’m glad you enjoyed it, James! I appreciate your review.
Lin
I made this today and we loved it so much! Thank you for another delicious recipe Kate! I always have trouble getting my potatoes to have flavor in potato salad but not this time!
Ana Woodley
Deelish!! Love the flavor as opposed to vinegar!!
Charlene Crivellone
I made this recipe a few times. As I needed a gulten free,soyfree,egg free, ect ect option. It is delicious. My husband family loves it.
Kate
Love to hear that, Charlene!
Sarah
I don’t like mayo, so I was so glad to find this recipe! I really like it!
Two questions:
1. Cucumber isn’t available where I live. Is there any other veggie you’d recommend instead? It tastes great just leaving it out too though.
2. Would it be possible to freeze some of it?
Kate
Hi Sarah, Which recipe are you referring to? This recipe doesn’t require cucumbers?
Sarah
Oh so sorry! I meant celery. :)
Kate
3 stalks, it’s the last ingredient in the list.
Shari Smith
This is my go to potato salad recipe! My cousin called to make sure I will be asking it for a party tomorrow. I wish you would write another cookbook!
Gina
I love this recipe! It always gets great reviews from family and friends too! Just a heads up if you choose to double or triple the recipe, it doubles/triples the size of the potato slices too. Stick to 1/4 inch- perfection!
Kim
Yum! I used half a small brown onion instead of spring onion (tasted good to us, still) as I didn’t have any spring onion on hand and lovage from the garden instead of celery. Also added 3 boiled and chopped eggs. Loved the tangy dressing. Will definitely make again!
Kate
Thank you for sharing how you made this work for you, Kim!
JennieC
I love this recipe. I have made it for many family parties and it’s always a hit for the vegans and non vegans alike. <3
Benita Maby
Thank you Kate for this beautiful vibrant salad. My son and his partner are both vegan and it is so refreshing to find a salad that didn’t have mayonnaise. I grow my own herbs so had fun adding some coriander to the parsley. This is perfect for our Australian summer.
Love from Lake Cathie, Australia
Helen Stephanou
Really delicious potato salad, family loves it!
Tara
This potato tasted so fresh and flavourful! I served it at two Christmas lunches and everyone loved it. I live in Australia, it’s currently summer and it was perfect for the weather and complimented all of the seafood and Christmas ham. Thank you!
Samboy
Really yum! Was very simple and could taste the potato. Love that it’s vegan. Served with slow cooked corned beef and your raw broccoli salad recipe. Was a hit. Thank you !
Paulo Sérgio da Cunha
I can’t wait to try this potato salad! The ingredients are great! I prefer to peel potatoes after cooking them. Congratulations! Thanks for the recipe!
Kate
I hope you love it, Paulo!
Sam
We made this last night and it was the perfect BBQ side. I can’t eat raw garlic so used half garlic oil and half olive oil and it turned out great. Really refreshing and light. Thank you!
Kate
You’re welcome, Sam!
Meredith
Great dish! Have made it for years
Kate
I love to hear that, Meredith! Thank you for your review.
Bill
First I made this according to the recipe. Next time I added dill for most of the parsley.
Both were great.
Third time I replaced the potatoes with steamed cauliflower, increased the garlic a little, decreased the lemon and didn’t add any extra liquid. I think it’s really good.
Thanks
Jody
This was so good! The dressing is amazing and I could see it used in a pasta salad or even a hot pasta dish. It has that je ne sais quoi flavor that brings it to the next level — maybe it’s the dijon and lemon juice — but whatever it is, it makes the dressing sing. Thank you!
Kate
You’re welcome, Jody. I’m excited you enjoyed it!
Jane
Oh my goodness!! These are amazing!! Needed something quick to take for tea at friend’s tomorrow and I came across. I need to steer clear from butter. I was not quite sure what to expect with the olive and rosemary. Just sampled some and YUMMMM!!! Love the savoriness! Neither the olive oil or the rosemary are overpowering.
Do you think this would work substituting the rosemary with lavender?
Kate
Wonderful, Jane! I don’t know if lavender would work or not. Sounds interesting!
Julie Frisch
This is a delicious recipe. I have made it before to rave reviews. However, I think a measurement is off or something is missing: You say to prepare 2/3 cup each of green onions and parsley but to make the dressing, you say to use 1/3 cup of each. Then you say to use a few Tablespoons of each at the end as garnish. So what happens to the other 1/3 cups of green onions and parsley? Please let me know. THANKS!
Kate
I’m glad you loved it, Julie! I appreciate your review.
Irma
I made this for a hot weekend spring barbecue because the idea of mayo potato salad sitting in the sun makes me nervous… It was a hit for sure! Absolutely foolproof recipe, thanks!
Kate
I’m happy you think so, Irma! Thank you for your review.
Alimama
Spectacular! What a nice departure from mayo based potato salads and packed with so much flavor. I used golden potatoes and probably added a touch more potato water to my dressing so it looked very herby, but even my potato salad averse tribe devoured this. Tripled the recipe for a big family dinner and sadly no leftovers. This definitely goes into the recipe file for regular rotation, as does every recipe I have tried on this site. Thank you!
Kate
You’re welcome, Alimama! I appreciate your review.
Mary S
I just tried this. I didn’t have all the ingredients listed, so I used baked potatoes instead of red, and cilantro instead of parsley. I can tell red potatoes are a better choice. ;) But the dressing is delicious! I was wondering which type of olive oil is best to use.
Kate
Thank you for sharing, Mary!
Stacey I Davis Jones
Help! I am making this delicious looking potato salad (Herbed Potato Salad (no mayo!) for a huge group tomorrow (both vegans and non) and I was wondering if I could make the dressing in advance? Obviously I’d have to add the potato water before dressing the potatoes but do you think it would work? I’m already exhausted and was hoping to make things easier tomorrow.
Thanks,
Stacey
Kate
Hi Stacey, what did you decide to do? I find this works best as written.
Sarah
Honestly I never felt like parsley was an herb it’s more of a tasteless weed. Where is the favor here? Salt pepper celery parsley green onion. Where are the herbs?
Kate
I’m sorry you didn’t love this, Sarah. I appreciate your review and feedback.
Kate Klebanski
These are an instant classic. So delicious!
Katie
My husband was very suspicious of this no Mayo potato salad but he (and I) loved it! I’ve made it several times— it’s going to be on rotation for sure this summer. Yum!
Kate
I love to hear that, Katie! Thank you for sharing.
Meredith
Hi Kate! I’ve cooked many of your recipes and they’re all delicious. I’m so excited to make this one on Friday but I do have a question.. do you have any recommendations on what I could potentially do ahead of time to save minutes leading up to hosting? Could I boil the potatoes and make the sauce the night before and not dress the potatoes until right when we’re ready for dinner? Would love your input!
Kate
This is best to make all together right away. I hope you try it!
Susan
Wow! This was super good. Had to come up with a potato salad recipe that did not have mayo in it due to a guest’s allergies to eggs so happened across your recipe. Have never made potatoes using this method but they held together and it all looked and tasted wonderful. Was loved by everyone and completely gone. So much better than a mayo based potato salad. Thanks!!
Kate
I’m glad it was a hit, Susan! I appreciate your review.
Dawn Klein
Made this tonight. My daughter was looking for a non-creamy potato salad. We all thought it was delicious.
Kate
I’m glad you loved it, Dawn! Thank you for your review.
Kristen
Omg I LOVE this. So simple and fresh and an absolute crowd pleaser.
Kate
I love to hear that, Kristen!
Barry
Hey Kate…. I have some fresh ground cherry tomatoes that are so sweet… What would you think about quartering these cherry tomatoes in adding them to the potato salad or does it change the dynamics of the dish too much?
Kate
I recommend this best as written. If you try it, let me know!
Sherry Johnson
Love this recipe! The flavor is so fresh and light. I actually prefer it the next day (in the rare occasion that there is any left over). Now a standard at every summer picnic gathering I host. In fact I have a big bowl made up today for our 4th of July vegan barbeque.
Kate
Great to hear, Sherry!
deborah
I halved the recipe, and pretty sure my arithmetic was correct. But the ratio of solid to liquid didn’t work. Not nearly enough liquid to soak into the potatoes, and the result was not much flavor.
Kate
Oh no! I hope you try this recipe again in the noted quantities. Let me know if you do!